Birthday This or That Questions

Press a side for each raised hand: balloons or streamers, frosting or filling, open now or save for later.

This or that?

1 of 72

How it works

These birthday this or that questions are picks the whole party votes on: Balloons or streamers, Frosting or filling, Musical chairs or freeze dance. No pair treats a birthday as bad news or asks what a present cost.

Read the full guide

Vote around the cake

Read both options aloud. Guests stand for the first and stay seated for the second. Press a side once for each guest, then Next question. The birthday person votes last and breaks a tie.

Match the set to the moment

Press Topic. Cake and treats fills the wait while the candles are lit, and Presents and cards suits opening time: Guess first or rip it open. A week ahead, run The party as a real poll, Bowling party or skating party, and put the winner on the plan.

Tips
  • Under Topic, Easy keeps to quick picks for the youngest guests, such as Pointy party hats or paper crowns.
  • Under Topic, Getting older is for the birthday person alone: Later bedtime or bigger bike, Double digits or teen years.

Questions and answers

What are some birthday this or that questions?

Rainbow sprinkles or chocolate curls? Pin the tail or break the piñata? One big present or many small ones? A wish said aloud or a wish kept quiet? Every pair prints in the list under the deck, grouped by topic.

Do these work for a grown-up's birthday?

Yes. Most pairs have no age in them: Tall layer cake or wide sheet cake, On the exact date or on the nearest Saturday, An outing or a keepsake. Only the Getting older set is written for children.

Is anything on the cards unkind about age?

No. No pair treats a birthday as bad news, compares presents by price or mentions drinking or dating. Getting older here means a later bedtime, a bigger bike and double digits.

All 72 pairs

Cake and treats 12

  • Baked at home or bought at a bakery?
  • Cake before lunch or cake after lunch?
  • Cupcake tower or giant cookie?
  • Decorate your own cake or a cake kept secret?
  • Extra-frosting slice or plain middle slice?
  • Frosting or filling?
  • Fruit on top or frosting flowers?
  • Rainbow sprinkles or chocolate curls?
  • Scoop beside the slice or scoop on the slice?
  • Share the final piece or keep it for tomorrow?
  • Tall layer cake or wide sheet cake?
  • Tall thin candles or chunky number candles?

The party 12

  • Balloons or streamers?
  • Bowling party or skating party?
  • Capes for everyone or animal ears for everyone?
  • Favor bags for all or prizes to win?
  • Garden party or park pavilion party?
  • Lunchtime party or sleepover party?
  • Mailed invitations or hand-delivered invitations?
  • On the exact date or on the nearest Saturday?
  • Party with a theme or party with no theme?
  • Plan your own party or let others plan it?
  • Pointy party hats or paper crowns?
  • Whole class invited or three best friends?

Games and music 12

  • A magician or a puppeteer?
  • Balloon stomp or bubble chase?
  • Dance floor or sing-along corner?
  • Face painting or balloon animals?
  • Host picks the music or guests pick the music?
  • Limbo line or hoop contest?
  • Musical chairs or freeze dance?
  • Pass the parcel or hot potato?
  • Pin the tail or break the piñata?
  • Relay teams or solo dashes?
  • Sing it loudly or hum along quietly?
  • Treasure hunt or relay race?

Presents and cards 12

  • A hand-drawn card or a rhyming card?
  • A puzzle or a storybook?
  • A total surprise or something you chose?
  • An outing or a keepsake?
  • Big bows or curly ribbons?
  • Giving a present or getting a present?
  • Guess first or rip it open?
  • One big present or many small ones?
  • Open now or save for later?
  • Shake the box or read the tag?
  • Thank-you drawing or thank-you phone call?
  • Unwrap neatly or tear the paper?

Wishes and traditions 12

  • A door banner or a decorated chair?
  • A wish for you or a wish for others?
  • A wish said aloud or a wish kept quiet?
  • All candles at once or one by one?
  • Awake before dawn or asleep until noon?
  • Choose the flavor or choose the game?
  • Coin-in-fountain wish or first-star wish?
  • Mark your height or take a yearly photo?
  • Pancake breakfast or favorite supper?
  • Song sung quickly or song sung slowly?
  • The usual birthday ritual or a brand-new one?
  • Wear a birthday crown or wear a birthday badge?

Getting older 12

  • A leap-day birthday or a New Year birthday?
  • A loud celebration or a cozy celebration?
  • A new privilege or a new responsibility?
  • Celebrate half-birthdays or one birthday is plenty?
  • Count down for weeks or let it sneak up?
  • Double digits or teen years?
  • Later bedtime or bigger bike?
  • Poolside birthday or snowy birthday?
  • Remember last year's or imagine next year's?
  • Share a birthday or have your own?
  • Suddenly older or exactly the same?
  • Taller this year or faster this year?
How this list was compiled

Own work: birthday pairs written for this page on 2026-09-30 and screened against the site's clean-deck rules the same day. Every option is one to four words, so both fit on a button. No brand, real person or title of a work is named, and the birthday song is called the birthday song. No pair is about age as bad news, what a present cost, drinking or dating, and no pair states a fact: every card is a matter of taste, from cake and party plans to games, presents, wishes and growing a year older. Levels are an editor's estimate. Compared by script on 2026-09-30 with every other deck on this site, including every this or that deck, this-or-that-generator, would-you-rather-questions, birthday-questions-for-adults, birthday-bingo and birthday-trivia-questions: no pair is shared. No outside page was read for this list. Licence: own work