Valentines This or That Questions for Class and Office Parties

Press an answer to vote on friends, cards and candy, with no romance on any card.

This or that?

All 86 questions

Candy and treats 13

  • Box of mixed chocolates or one big chocolate heart?
  • Caramel-filled chocolate or mint-filled chocolate?
  • Chocolate-covered strawberries or chocolate-covered pretzels?
  • Cinnamon candies or cherry candies?
  • Dark chocolate heart or white chocolate heart?
  • Eat your candy today or save it all week?
  • Frosted sugar cookie or crispy rice treat?
  • Gummy hearts or heart lollipops?
  • Heart-shaped cookie or heart-shaped pizza?
  • Pink frosting or red frosting?
  • Rainbow sprinkles or heart sprinkles?
  • Strawberry cupcake or chocolate cupcake?
  • Strawberry shortcake or cherry pie?

Cards and crafts 13

  • Animal puns or food puns?
  • Card in cursive or card in block letters?
  • Card with a pun or card with a compliment?
  • Googly eyes or pipe cleaners?
  • Monster mailbox or robot mailbox?
  • One design for all or a design per friend?
  • Origami heart or pop-up card?
  • Pink envelope or red envelope?
  • Roses are red rhyme or knock-knock joke?
  • Scissors and glue or markers and stamps?
  • Shoebox mailbox or paper bag mailbox?
  • Tiny card or giant card?
  • Write a poem or draw a picture?

Class and office party 12

  • Candy jar guessing game or heart beanbag toss?
  • Cookie decorating station or card making station?
  • Everyone brings a treat or one big shared cake?
  • Heart bingo or heart scavenger hunt?
  • Heart socks or heart sweater?
  • Heart-shaped balloons or paper heart garland?
  • Morning party or last-hour party?
  • Open cards right away or open cards at home?
  • Party music on or quiet party?
  • Pass out cards first or eat treats first?
  • Shared treat table or treats at each desk?
  • Silly photo corner or quiet craft corner?

Friendship 12

  • Board game with friends or walk with friends?
  • Friend who arrives early or friend who stays late?
  • Friend who plans or friend who wings it?
  • Help a friend move or help a friend study?
  • Inside joke or secret handshake?
  • Letter in the mail or message on a screen?
  • Long talk or comfortable quiet?
  • Matching shirts or matching bracelets?
  • Old friend or new friend?
  • Remembers your birthday or remembers your favorite snack?
  • Share your umbrella or share your blanket?
  • Throw a surprise party or plan a quiet hangout?

Kind things to do 11

  • Bake for a neighbor or shovel for a neighbor?
  • Call a grandparent or visit a grandparent?
  • Care home cards or fire station cookies?
  • Cheer a friend on or quietly pitch in?
  • Let someone go first or save someone a seat?
  • Note in a lunchbox or note on a desk?
  • Say thanks out loud or write thanks down?
  • Sidewalk chalk hearts or sticky note hearts?
  • Sign your kind note or leave it a mystery?
  • Thank the crossing guard or thank the lunch staff?
  • Thank-you note or thank-you high five?

Customs near and far 10

  • Call it Friend's Day or call it Valentine's Day? In Finland, February 14 is ystävänpäivä, which means Friend's Day: a day for remembering friends. Estonia's name for it, sõbrapäev, means the same.
  • Card for the teacher or card for the custodian? Count the cards children swap at school and teachers receive more valentines than anyone, by the U.S. Greeting Card Association estimate that Wikipedia reports.
  • Celebrate in February or celebrate in September? Colombia keeps its Love and Friendship Day, Día del amor y la amistad, on the third Saturday in September.
  • Conversation hearts or foil-wrapped chocolate hearts? Conversation hearts, small candies with short messages on them, are strongly tied to the day in the United States.
  • First flowers of spring or last snow of winter? In Slovenian folk tradition, Saint Valentine is one of the saints of spring, and plants and flowers are said to start growing on his day.
  • Heart-shaped box or plain box, more chocolate? Heart-shaped boxes of chocolates go back to 1868, when a British chocolate maker sold decorated ones for the day.
  • Paper hearts or paper doves? The heart outline, doves and a winged Cupid are the symbols the day uses now.
  • Paper lace card or bold cartoon card? Esther Howland of Worcester, Massachusetts, sold the first mass-produced American valentines shortly after 1847. They were made of embossed paper lace.
  • Secret friend gift swap or a card for everyone? In the Dominican Republic and El Salvador, people play amigo secreto, which means secret friend, a gift game much like Secret Santa.
  • Treat on the doorstep or treat handed to you? In Norfolk, England, a figure named Jack Valentine raps at the back door and leaves sweets and presents for children.

Would you rather 15

  • Would you rather deliver every valentine by paper airplane or pull them all around in a wagon?
  • Would you rather eat nothing but chocolate all day or nothing but gummy hearts all day?
  • Would you rather find a surprise note today or a surprise treat tomorrow?
  • Would you rather get a card with a terrible pun or a card with a terrible drawing of you?
  • Would you rather get one card you keep for years or thirty cards you forget by March?
  • Would you rather have a valentine mailbox that sings or a valentine mailbox that glows in the dark?
  • Would you rather have two Valentine's Days a year or a small party every month?
  • Would you rather it rained candy hearts for an hour or snowed pink glitter for an hour?
  • Would you rather live next door to your best friend or sit beside your best friend all year?
  • Would you rather make cards with glitter that never comes off or glue that never dries?
  • Would you rather make every decoration for the party or bake every treat for the party?
  • Would you rather read every card you get out loud or sing just one of them to the room?
  • Would you rather share a cupcake the size of a desk or keep a cake the size of a coin?
  • Would you rather wear a giant heart costume all day or heart-shaped glasses all week?
  • Would you rather write fifty short kind notes or one kind note fifty lines long?

How it works

These valentines this or that questions are about friends, cards and candy, with no romance anywhere: 86 short pairs in 7 groups, from Monster mailbox or robot mailbox to Say thanks out loud or write thanks down. A press on either button is a vote, and the count stays on this phone or computer. Fifteen pairs are worded as would you rather questions.

Read the full guide

Run it at a class party or a team meeting

In a classroom, read both options aloud, have students stand for the first and stay seated for the second, then press an answer once per student. Next question brings the next pair. At work, pass one phone around the treat table.

Which topic fits which party

Candy and treats (13 pairs) and Cards and crafts (13) cover the day itself: Shoebox mailbox or paper bag mailbox. Class and office party has 12 for whoever is planning. Friendship (12) and Kind things to do (11) work any week. Customs near and far has 10 pairs with a fact in the list, and Would you rather, the last topic, has 15 longer dilemmas. Press Topic to see it.

  • Run Class and office party as a real poll a week ahead: Everyone brings a treat or one big shared cake.
  • Start on Easy, 30 quick picks such as Pink envelope or red envelope. The Hard pairs, such as Long talk or comfortable quiet, earn a follow-up why.
  • Turn a Kind things to do vote into a job: whichever side wins, Sidewalk chalk hearts or sticky note hearts, the class does it by Friday.

Questions and answers

Are these Valentine's Day this or that questions right for a classroom?

Yes. The deck is about friendship, cards and treats. No card mentions dating, crushes or partners, none asks a player to pick a favorite person in the room, and treats are named without brands.

Do these work as valentine would you rather questions?

Yes. Pick Would you rather for 15 valentines would you rather questions such as Would you rather write fifty short kind notes or one kind note fifty lines long? The card shows each side as a short button, and the list under the deck gives the full wording. More dilemmas sit in the would you rather deck.

Why is there a card about Friend's Day?

Because February 14 is not about couples everywhere. In Finland the day is ystävänpäivä, Friend's Day. In the Dominican Republic and El Salvador people play amigo secreto, a gift game much like Secret Santa. Each note under Customs near and far was checked against Wikipedia's Valentine's Day article.